1012 2015-07-08 13:56:25 +0000 Missed send_request while completing a forward request 2015-10-22 04:41:22 +0000 1 1 1 Unclassified JacORB ORB 3.6.1 PC All RESOLVED FIXED P5 major --- 1 hroenick jacorb-bugs hroenick jacorb mesnierp vgpinheiro oldest_to_newest 3321 0 466 hroenick 2015-07-08 13:56:25 +0000 Created attachment 466 demo that demonstrate the suspicious behaviour I stumbled in another unexpected behaviour while isolating the problem reported in Bug 1011 . Instead of making 2 or more calls inside the send_request interception point, just make 1 more call that is also going to receive an exception and resolve it through a forward_request. In this case I noticed that there is an extra send_request call and the previous one apparently is not completed (does not arrives in server side). Let me try to make myself clear with an example: [client] [server] ---- calls A() ----> <---- NO_PERMISSION (op = A) ---- receive_exception: do forward_request( op = A ) ---- calls A() ----> ---- send_request( op = A ) ----> ---- calls B() ----> <---- NO_PERMISSION (op = B) ---- receive_exception: do forward_request( op = B ) ---- calls B() ----> <---- successful reply (op = B) ---- --- complete the send_request( op = A) ---> // "apparently this completed send_request does not arrives to the server" // why ??? // an extra call is sent. Why?? ---- calls A() ----> <---- successful reply (op = A) ---- 3322 1 hroenick 2015-07-08 13:56:46 +0000 Through the provided demo this can we noticed by the following prints: send_request: canIComeIn canIComeIn -> secret = Any wrong secret receive_exception: canIComeIn send_request: canIComeIn send_request: itsMe itsMe -> secret = Any wrong secret receive_exception: itsMe send_request: itsMe itsMe -> secret = This is truly the real one! canIComeIn -> secret = This is truly the real one! // this print below is the extra call send_request: canIComeIn canIComeIn -> secret = This is truly the real one! 3328 2 jacorb 2015-07-31 09:24:28 +0000 Hugo - would it be possible to verify current git head to ensure that it is fixed there? 3330 3 hroenick 2015-08-03 05:32:48 +0000 Will test it and get back to you as soon as possible. 3335 4 vgpinheiro 2015-08-19 14:48:05 +0000 I've already informed this on the jacorb-dev list, but just for the record i'll duplicate the info: this bug was not fixed by the current git head. I submitted a pull request to reproduce it. 3351 5 mesnierp 2015-10-01 17:18:30 +0000 Here's the deal with the extra call. In the regression test ExtraCall case, the itsMe operation gets a NO_PERMISSION which triggers the forward. This causes the Delegate to rebind, closing the existing connection and making a new one. The itsMe call completes allowing the original canIComeIn request to proceed. At this point, the Delegate throws a RemarshalException from within _invoke_internal because the connection it expected to use no longer exists. So I will adjust the regression test to use all three scenarios but I think this issue is resolved. 3362 6 mesnierp 2015-10-22 04:41:22 +0000 with commit b1c67af0d4efb973e76aa2dcbce593b4eecef3d9 the regression test fits the behavior of the Delegate which is correct given the connection manager's closure of unbound connections. It may be possible to continue caching otherwise unbound connections for some time but that will involve reworking the giop connection manager. 466 2015-07-08 13:56:25 +0000 2015-07-08 13:56:25 +0000 demo that demonstrate the suspicious behaviour door-demo.tar.gz application/x-gzip 4259 hroenick H4sIACFknVUAA+082W7suLFGcIPg+gPu00XA6TsB5Blbvdtzvd342J6kB8cLbE9mkAUNWWK35aMW FUrykoG/Jr+TlzzkB5KH/Mat4qKtpV48ts9kIsK9iCwWi6yFVUW6Hca4QyesufJ6pdVqbfX7RHxu ys9Wpyc/VSHtTr+31dls9Xst0mp3N3utFdJ/RZqSEoeRxYGUG86o79ofquAAbDSagUfNI/n8FymO 5r8Z0ihy/XH48pKwDP97nT7wv9/frPn/JiXhv+t4r2UDltL/Lup/r9faqvn/FiXV/2HAJubDxHv5 MWA9Nnu9av53QecL+t/d6q2Q1suTMl3+zfm/8tP/+tnKT1ZWTiybnF2Sb4kqWLfyn/DqwOvP8MLn vy2G8uDq6kJ9xR5/UZiy5Seq/qcrKz+3Qe4mls3ZxIpoCPuQR+3IZf6F5Y+pgv8rvP5jZeW/C7B3 buhee3TgO/RhZWWrtd3rttudN5GbH0lJ9P/VtH+u/vfam1P7fxv3/1r/X7/sBpzdgr4R4L0f7jVu oijYbjYn1h31TSuw7BtqMj5unp+dNHtmy2w1JOT2Q+gm0Pf39+Z9V8B1Wq1289uT95fQcWJtuD6s m2/Txioh0GM7FNXvmW2hhi8wHKmCEBUbd71ha9gyH0KnsQ9D7E6YQ73fUB4C9n2BYLeZq1tFqDFn cTBw9lHwd5v6CVssHrkjy47gceBHlNs0iBh/F493m5kmhLxTCNs4hH7ABiDxgzUGT3r/1uK7zfRR DO1bE7p/BOOSDVIcQbQJKGBKQGE8GiJKqLi17iwzHXJzt5mr0UA249dJZdfcNNsImKuVoODt3Wbw dRAwVyfBlHCY17HrOWbIYiD32LeZg/MZXJ5tfPFF/383oO9MQJxRMzslrBCQahgJf+RyQMH4437I 7d1msXJVkeTFsJqhekwq9lf1zpVwF6REC4yUHtU1x3HVJ8NcKViw0QSuR/mG7FRkv+qmV6tjds1O TgwUgM38kTuOuRD3tD6Z8/6n32UZ+aSnnQMFAzWm0TSoqs+CarIP+DieUD/a3/j2mrHI9qwwDKzo phlsf/qdjvRMD/TQu6ABC11c4qcmKpaUF/2Bg2bl50k1bEw1mELcpwhI16JZuhggGYqBCzEURIre WHFoTtgtm8NJFOgNyc6FuPjpd1kVeCrhZ9rHoQEFr8O3Ex0tNjxmqwuzkEtXQn5xCmqxga5EIssn UZhIgTclU8GVL6M1U6t1da4sa9L29bySimmJTxUaJlWi5ZXikrbQB2rHWJlf+aS6sCrBjRXS/TH1 KaCiG3JEsAKyvsAkZnlhvk7VJgiAa/iY79ec6rjbLKEnUxlWKIB+DKXZVGZytVTkSoRtETGbFrAy mVpYmnJyRFanRSjZHmAeH9vfqUu+JP4/7Lk/hPyP9P97EMfV+Z+3KDn+v9JBwFL877VF/qffrfn/ FmWa/1jzskKwBP872NBqb3bb/Zr/b1Gm+X9JOWzvF/SPMQ2jTIg6mASeiRHI0mPMyf90sTFn/zu9 Nub/6/zP6xeZnqAEWb+zuupOAsYjkjqPJr7OLt7tZJvYZGweQuWBeeA/VrQcQgjgUfR0LyMrisMK sMHp1fHF6cH7imbMFHln1+g8VkCcng3Pjy9OBpeXg7PTKZjB2TlQ4lC7tAVF3bXpIQMpf5ge4Bwe LJFeTpTA/JLxe4s7Sj0W6lJQqBF7Tq+kAZg0cn3LI0F87bk2EaE9maW0BOYG3nhIMotJXOQOBugh OOxVvcl3GHgE3L2DuIdcRtz1xwSzVDuZauACTOQ6WyVWnNhy3bFekjqLSENhD8XHusa6nsW1BvRg wBHduKGJZJA9Bb+T1kMnqFYEqTrRG2oVRYQ8IVW/PANquOvQlMI75joEQlHq3tEhl4QaU/wj3F0D xJzdhyQvD4rA68eI/u4PhGICjDqHnEIoFLnAsz3ix54nKcsLH1GjFWr3VDDGXXNMI03SMJRQQ1uC GekQquPAMe8sL6ZrcqwySkoHNBXGoWNFluwLKk4sVHOxnPxRzZFgpV5TE17wORRjGlOjAReT77+m XkC5GT0G1FhT5D2Jd9uK7BtiHD+gVIDdIHQtGUtJx4SGIVqrPdL42qcPAUgydQhwEWRVkIBAdjJW Y0d1F8wiPr0n2t4YClWOgsz62NmlmqIeVohDsGzAEigE7ogYn4BFujg+vBpeHh9eHF9JDpiwzJYX GilCM6TwEK2ls0vJy1kzo4XinzejYPVOzt8fXx0fDU/PMsQvI9FF8QnLRXw1Ia1EzOcNGYLFGVLN yiV1aCHkLLqh/DUQcxp4jxWI56NwAJyzR2MObMaYGloQQChi7qfmTVqqp1fNmVT4/0fwdui5ILDP c/lyZY7/1+lt9vP+f6fdwfi/9v9ev2T9PxNZnzqB4rTBZea7eDSiYL0uqOVQvlNs/tL1aGllGXwc uZ55nhwF5T3O1KkTDqduEqQdCdKKNdIcA6jSKukZSZcoFWHlxkgQ4GMEH9gKCjfamWq5AgU+tEJK Ihved6a7CjWfWK5vyOGkKsN+b/FxmNiedBuTyp1OmuBRWIi+ABj8tNpQ1ly04m081fRoNKYW5xBn 2FgnjWlHvbEEmkugGzYX5it8ajsqwZpALoC+zJsFFAPfxd3P/RPlYjizoYb7nDRUM8wI+ZKBNAUv 0fc5FZZSja68Q1hD+Ga6AG/g4q9LstZ2ZCodhZCM1ELjg9FACQf55Hoaedkm11xB5+sNjUA9jjQd yooDQuh3zU0O7e9dn2peXuMEWCieRUWBBdIXZ9e30mU1pTc7jNiQiSYDMCtUzSaJQxws9u0ban+g sHdwdBtuwYKRiBFLyKWbLnpILHGPJhT9tcDDrHwbPahUf0yN0hlKnAaMroaFHsJXVP0SWvThDKjJ DVqP0IXVIhFus6g2CkyoEPTXOmV+w/iHr4DgL2GRdqqAjnDTPWeBcjmLzcfofB1a6EdrEiVxpm35 A3CYQPIkA56mlZf68SRVcamaWaKkDiRDyMcsQa+9Ib9xmbv/v0AiaM7+v9XZKuT/O/3NXr/e/9+i zNv/xYYNym7HnKM3aEVs4trmgfh4x5hHLb9qF69ODr1s1kd7AdWuxEtmhZLO53LpzIEPgZ7rXEFE CwGHvvWyUJKnoGILpoaqFPNZCaycT5UPYPP+VhoEV9UnuYcqgMRdK8lgzbM4ZVms1TSLRar6vlgO S9XDBgu1uMfAntTaKbS4UXhCiw05ZUEwzpxY7MHoV+RajZHlhXQt63XOW5iPkDkrrCZ4Z5cipaFJ YYEeUKwJ9G+nWRIW6JRII92vG5lsiCvGw9rPP9cJHPA4kB4Cfxa5h/3a4iz2HfR70P9oJBt2Q7gf pkYF47nkF6RL9oAn6RBJrN3A7NY9Z7h+YgpJyuhJfVIv8RMy/coyPcWeQPPx6VGG2kymSWAtrIaQ neJCiEq9Dk+rySrirDqFWc2ZU2bkQo/q2cxNLamMicyUTpmzuZnSRGCovOaDvqZrJo/aj758DCM6 MVkcmSB7fuT5RiM78jZpQBiRdMvk5BJtM/FOksXpge9cgqRGPKbrRGpbuoLhvStykJn0h3A/s5Ij 3NGsy7idNJGMskIsMDI/+Mz+MBTvRuOc+v6jDjxkuYaA4cNOHrV2Nr8HWpC8DigymTDwzwWYeret OIQAFFXmOh4/f4AXmGaisdt5woWaCzoJGMuGyLQ2cmJGkjtUZr4rmBOfRRAgQYyG144dcn9jReTG CgLq08RYBJzeuSwOCfOpWT0poXlG4/KGek4a95ZM6Cmrmypbnsu0Y2QHeggWcwhNRj52lCoKUKkV LcpxifSnCgPRM9nYT9GgIqgE887MpDbuPWmbUdFHRYiuH0KQb+Rmtp7Bp+PdioOP6cODshMJeZQg W9RRQm7AstOCcudryaMD6n/vo4OlTnMQW76p+gRnfXqpdGjumpbjVJ4JlZKgTd7Ch2BpCv8Zxr3E ak/hlaY7b/Qz9jvfMM9zSIx9qEx8jkcKnyIhczwxdJ0Ud0loYWJ76XlNft6IXV7Kzh1tLbTQ8jhj uUVeFLc80SjHveChSMA879kYXvxMZPXpY8fNP5YyI//z/As/hTIn/9Paam8V8j9QVed/3qTMyP8k pyznZwfVRyy52FxBSzWvsgZZbzGj8mszdg0BvE7yH7hviI46kVzW85sbhkEjGlf6f435+570+hYk 6/eNQYTYNSXojP2+MXuUa5UGyOaqZwxx9uETvAOA2QUSQMeQftJIUvPSNPI4sYrLZ6Zn6X/mGOZ7 mYE5+t9rbRXv/3U6W/X9vzcpM/S/cAoYVB/roSuAdqAy2zu4Ghy8H/z2+Bn53tm5WtHypSX+d6gU 4Pj08OxocPqr4eHRxRAeDs4vy+Gq0rbFUXTW92sfzNC9v1S6N7Ncy8ArJVx2CE3pURyA4YHo81T4 TznzPutK3gybnxI1/3JhfhJya2h+9hk5sW7x1pZF8J+J/sGIwzAAdEdAqgMTIZ81M5lGdXonCcEo k5Qwdnhy8NXZxfA3xxfouuusoxjL9V98rMFpbqzOzqxtJeB0KI6pM/wBkz5i2vYXNEm0iS97xCi0 rYlGFainOV4MoEWSQdQZGsHadOyNTSJ0tIU/n0SQmbNjceI9N/OcZEQaVWCN9WQmeIgPMzHW1lVO OsmoJPSEQhor6Zl5fzSlpQpsAVpyqYWc3iyZUeB07MJmLm8HZI7kS9MK2jqWJBZm+ioBE4tUIVW6 N8g/ovuMHHLXIvHEIvhP+X/3bXgCPZASZEGUxwke9rl/ApUgAfVYmFKOWkJDkSxTyH4ZWNyaiMHE G59Y/5SKBbQoEOWgqDFk76yiKeHNCG2VdmQNsOSYftiT0iPqhiNZmdy2SNNB+ks2A6NbjRL1VrmX RKjmWpv1+UZCU5VVRbVE2SnpVKGoMzTlZQJa2IKWFFExjEh64UDLC+aP6hrEv22Z4f9LO/oG9z9b m5sF/7/d2azvf75JWeD+J158O4ujII7AqlBrMnXZ8xyD1W+4G32f254Vvq0SQpGCmAsy7zqohCy7 Dlrf6ZyN/gdzpxOzSwGzACrht6kvLcK0wEth3p30tWG4YXI3MDQaF4xF0KmhBwQ0ZnRDh1B3Yvmg BNxYM/HKJDoniQ+R5LhQORSDdZ1mr5SZGXc7cSh0bi3wtiOWUmUg0rK7pIJNAgPCy6sa6lamkrxE 5UhG7pLK5MZqVnGz11/1GoRJqim9agqVxVursLJxcqmy3vl/PCX3+582m0yYb8LXFx1jXv6/2ynk /9qb3a1uvf+/RZkwJ/bk9i/3NJtBdEhiP3THeGfCw2tEJYfTeMftAZjVx9nu4O2LxruvWy1p/zOI pOkq3DDCeORKXeeKeOw9insZYKI8vJPxiYpFxBv0j8GMZu4JJHd1svcnVGCyswp/tXVaouT0X24P L6z98/W/0+kW9b/Vq3//9U3KlP6LnM/Isqn8jxGtbVMnd66vNTBzBkeyh2gVEGUHYLX6fqxS8vvv 6MdS23ODkJq3Dv5LOKfgJdJR+Mwx5u7/7W7x/K/frc//3qT8z1VMyVexR1pbpPXFdvuLbSD+3cUV 6bTa/dVSUdA/7ieSrmPqqytP554VYR54r21urupOQRqA6Z+P22vPQSt/oE+gmTc+xGAu/rysAP7Y S1mXutSlLnWpS13qUpe61KUudalLXepSl7rUpS4/qPL/diD3cwB4AAA=